“You’ve got the memory of a goldfish.” It is one of those insults that has survived for generations, usually aimed at someone who has forgotten where they left their keys or what they were saying five minutes ago. The joke relies on the idea that a goldfish remembers something for only three seconds before forgetting it and starting again. It sounds plausible if you have ever watched one circle a bowl, and it is completely wrong.
So how long is a goldfish memory? There is no single number, because memory is not an on-off timer and different experiments test different kinds of learning. But goldfish can learn where food is, link sounds and sights with feeding, tell different cues apart and remember trained tasks for weeks and months afterwards. Whatever the true limit is, it is nowhere near three seconds.
A myth with no study behind it
One of the strangest things about the three-second figure is that nobody seems able to trace it to any experiment. It appears to be a popular myth rather than a shortened scientific finding, and it has stuck because it fits the stereotype of fish as simple animals with tiny brains. Popular culture has not helped. Dory, the famously forgetful fish from Finding Nemo, is often linked to the myth, as Neuro & Psycho points out, although she is actually a blue tang rather than a goldfish. The real experiments tell a very different story.
The goldfish that learned when lunch was
One of the clearest demonstrations comes from a 1994 study by Philip Gee, David Stephenson and Donald Wright at the University of Plymouth, published in the Journal of the Experimental Analysis of Behavior. Eight goldfish were trained to press a lever that released food. The researchers then gradually narrowed the window in which the lever worked until it produced food for just one hour in every 24, and kept the fish on that schedule for four weeks. The fish began responding far more around feeding time and much less for the rest of the day. When the dispensers were switched off for six days, the pattern of their responses still suggested they were anticipating the feeding period.
In other words, the fish were not just reacting when food appeared. They had learned a link between the time of day, their own behaviour and a reward, and kept acting on it, which is hard to square with an animal whose memory vanishes every few seconds. As BBC Wildlife puts it, goldfish can remember where, when and how to get food, and retain memories for at least three months.
The Adelaide teenager who tested the myth
One of the most entertaining challenges to the myth came from Adelaide in 2008. Rory Stokes, then a 15-year-old student at the Australian Science and Mathematics School, put a small red Lego block in his goldfish tank each day and sprinkled the food around it, as Big Bang Education describes. Over three weeks, the time his fish took to reach the block fell from more than a minute to under five seconds, according to Mental Floss. He then fed them for six days without it, and when he put it back, they swam straight to it.
It was not a peer-reviewed study, so it does not prove any particular memory length. But it is a lovely demonstration of associative learning. The fish did not need to know what Lego was; they simply learned that this particular red shape meant food. And Stokes had a pointed reason for doing it. As Neatorama reported, he believed the myth was intended to make us feel less guilty about keeping fish in small tanks. More on that below.
A maze remembered six months later
Another student project pushed the timescale further. In a three-year science project that won a 2015 Young Naturalist Award from the American Museum of Natural History, a student trained goldfish to find food in a maze and then retested them after gaps of up to six months. The fish found the food location significantly faster than they had on their first day of training. Like the Lego experiment, it should be read as a well-run student project rather than a major lab study. But it points the same way as the professional research: goldfish can hold on to what they have learned for months, not seconds.
More than one trick
Goldfish are capable of several kinds of learning. They can be trained to tell colours and shapes apart, to link sounds or other cues with food, to learn where food is and to find their way around simple environments. Even the TV show MythBusters got involved: co-host Jamie Hyneman trained his goldfish to recognise colour patterns and swim an underwater obstacle course, as Mental Floss notes. Every one of those skills depends on a fish remembering what happened before.
Can a goldfish recognise you?
If you have kept goldfish, you have probably seen them come to the front of the tank as you walk up. That behaviour is learned. Goldfish link particular people, sights and routines with being fed, and RSPCA Australia describes them as social and intelligent animals that can learn to recognise their human carers. That does not mean your goldfish is thinking, “Ah, there’s Daniel.” Recognition in animals is complicated, and a fish behaving differently around familiar people does not tell us exactly what is going on in its head. But it does show the fish has learned that a particular sight predicts something important, and that takes memory.
Which memory are we talking about?
There is a deeper problem with the question itself. Asking how long a goldfish’s memory lasts is a bit like asking how long a human’s memory lasts: which memory? A goldfish may hold a feeding routine differently from the location of food or an unpleasant experience, and some memories fade quickly while others last much longer. That is why scientists measure memory by teaching an animal a task and then testing whether it can still do it after a delay. By that standard, goldfish clearly have long-term memory. The precise maximum is not known, and no single number such as “three months” applies to everything a goldfish can remember. What the evidence does show is that goldfish keep learned information for weeks and months, with student experiments suggesting it can last even longer.
Why the myth matters for your goldfish
The three-second myth might seem harmless, but it props up another one: that goldfish are simple pets that will be fine in a tiny bowl because they will not remember their surroundings anyway. RSPCA Australia says otherwise. It recommends a tank of at least 50 litres, larger for more fish, and says traditional fish bowls are too small for goldfish and should be avoided. Good filtration, water quality, cover and enrichment all matter too. Goldfish also live far longer than many people expect: the RSPCA gives an average of 10 to 15 years, with some varieties reaching 30 when properly cared for, and according to Guinness World Records, as PetsRadar notes, the oldest known goldfish lived to 43. So the picture of a goldfish as a tiny animal that forgets everything within seconds points people in exactly the wrong direction. It is a long-lived fish that learns from its surroundings, and Rory Stokes was right to suspect the myth made us a little too comfortable with small bowls.
The next time someone tells you that you have the memory of a goldfish, you can point out that they may be paying your memory a compliment, and if you have a goldfish at home, it is paying far more attention to its world than the old stereotype suggests. If you enjoy this kind of animal myth-busting, you can also read about whether daddy long-legs really are the most venomous spiders in the world or whether sharks really get cancer.
Sources
- Gee, Stephenson and Wright: Temporal discrimination learning of operant feeding in goldfish, Journal of the Experimental Analysis of Behavior (1994)
- BBC Wildlife: Do goldfish really only have a three-second memory?
- Neuro & Psycho: The goldfish memory myth
- Big Bang Education: Goldfish memory
- Mental Floss: Do fish really have a three-second memory?
- Neatorama: Beacon experiment busts goldfish memory myth
- American Museum of Natural History: Goldfish as a model for understanding learning and memory (2015 Young Naturalist Award)
- RSPCA Australia: How should I care for my goldfish?
- PetsRadar: How long do goldfish live?
