Fruit or Vegetable

Is a tomato a fruit or a vegetable? What about pumpkin, capsicum or rhubarb? The answer depends on who you ask, because botanists and cooks use completely different definitions. That is the real difference between fruit and vegetables, and once you know it, a lot of kitchen arguments settle themselves.

Botanist’s definitionCook’s definition
FruitThe part of a plant that develops from the flower and holds the seedsSweet or tart, usually eaten raw or in desserts
VegetableAny other edible part: roots, stems, leaves, bulbs or flower budsSavoury, usually eaten as part of a main meal
TomatoFruitVegetable
RhubarbVegetable (it is a leaf stalk)Usually treated as a fruit

The botanist’s answer

To a botanist, a fruit is the part of a flowering plant that grows from the flower, specifically from its ovary, after it has been pollinated. Its job is to protect the seeds and help spread them, often by being tasty enough for an animal to eat and carry away. By that definition, tomatoes, cucumbers, pumpkins, zucchini, capsicums, eggplants, avocados, chillies and even corn kernels are all fruits.

“Vegetable”, on the other hand, is not really a botanical term at all. It is a catch-all for the other edible parts of plants: roots such as carrots and beetroot, tubers such as potatoes, stems such as celery, leaves such as lettuce and spinach, bulbs such as onions, and flower buds such as broccoli and cauliflower.

The answer in the kitchen

In the kitchen, the definitions are about taste and use, not anatomy. Fruits are generally sweet or tart and eaten raw, as snacks or in desserts, while vegetables are savoury and usually cooked or served with the main meal. That is why most of us call tomatoes, pumpkin and capsicum vegetables, even though they are botanical fruits, and why rhubarb, a leaf stalk, ends up in a crumble with the fruit.

Is a tomato a fruit or a vegetable? Ask the US Supreme Court

Botanically, a tomato is a fruit, and more specifically a berry. But the argument once went all the way to the United States Supreme Court. In 1886, an importer named John Nix brought a shipment of West Indian tomatoes into New York, and the port’s customs collector, Edward Hedden, charged a 10% import tax on them under a law that taxed foreign vegetables, but not fruit. Nix argued that, botanically, a tomato is a fruit, so it should be tax-free, as National Geographic recounts.

In 1893, in the case Nix v. Hedden, the court unanimously disagreed. Justice Horace Gray accepted that tomatoes were botanically the fruit of the vine, but ruled that in everyday language and use, they were vegetables, because they were served with the main meal rather than as dessert. So, at least for American tax purposes, the tomato is officially a vegetable.

Rhubarb, the vegetable that became a fruit

Rhubarb went the other way. Botanically, the part we eat is a leaf stalk, just like celery, which makes it a vegetable. But in 1947, a US customs court had to decide how to tax a shipment of Canadian rhubarb, and after hearing that it was mostly used in pies and sauces, it ruled that rhubarb should be classed as a fruit, as the law firm that argued the case, Barnes Richardson, explains. The same logic that made tomatoes vegetables made rhubarb a fruit: what mattered was how people ate it.

Bananas are berries, strawberries are not

If that is not confusing enough, botanists have their own definition of a berry: a fleshy fruit that develops from the ovary of a single flower. By that definition, bananas, tomatoes, cucumbers and avocados are all berries, while strawberries are not, because the juicy part grows from a different part of the flower, as The Daily Meal explains. Each of those little “seeds” on the outside of a strawberry is technically a tiny fruit of its own, with a seed inside. Seeds are not the deciding factor either, which is why seedless grapes, seedless watermelons and supermarket bananas still count as fruit: they all develop from a flower, even if the plant has been bred not to produce proper seeds.

A simple test

If you want a quick rule for the next argument, ask: did it grow from the flower? If yes, a botanist would call it a fruit, whether it is sweet like a mango or savoury like a pumpkin. If it is a root, stem, leaf, bulb or bud, it is a vegetable. But if you are writing a shopping list or planning dinner, the cook’s definition is perfectly fine; even the US Supreme Court agreed that, in the kitchen, a tomato is a vegetable.

Or, as a joke I once heard puts it: knowledge is knowing that a tomato is a fruit; wisdom is knowing not to put it in a fruit salad. If you enjoy food facts with a twist, my post on whether oranges were originally green has another surprise, and can an apple wake you up better than coffee? tests a popular food myth.

Sources

By Daniel Lutton

I'm Daniel, and I'm endlessly inquisitive. I write The Prodigious because learning something fascinating is only half the fun; the other half is sharing it. Each post starts with a question I couldn't stop thinking about and ends with the sources I used to answer it, so you can dig deeper if the rabbit hole calls to you too.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *